On April 6th, 1917 the US Congress declared war on Germany at the urging of President Wilson. Shortly thereafter, Americans headed off to fight in the European theater of World War I. Ninety years later, and under very different circumstances, the war in Iraq enters its fifth year. And as the present war has influenced the composition of popular music, the onset of WWI similarly stimulated songwriters of the 20th century's teens. Yet this analogy should only be taken so far: there is no recording of the era whose tone is remotely comparable to that of Neil Young's "Let's Impeach the President" in 2006. In fact, the jingoistic themes of WWI tunes, with their ubiquitous anti-German sentiment, are perhaps more closely echoed in modern times in songs like Toby Keith's "Courtesy of the Red, White and Blue (The Angry American)." Regardless of the parallels one chooses to draw, it is hard to overstate the effects of WWI on the popular culture of that time. With America's entry into the war, a torrent of patriotic songs, sheet music, and musical revues followed. These twenty-one cylinder recordings are a small sampling of this larger burst of war-fueled musical inspiration.
The program has been divided into six categories that broadly reflect some of the main themes of WWI music: Patriotic Americans Fighting Across the Foam; The Life of the Soldier, On and Off the Battlefield; Love During Wartime; The Fight Viewed from the Home Front; War Perpetuates the Status Quo; and Remembering the Troops.
For a more in-depth look at the music history of WWI, see Glenn Watkins's Proof Through the Night: Music and the Great War, which served as a valuable resource in compiling this program. —Noah Pollaczek, UCSB Cylinder Preservation and Digitization Project
Patriotic Americans Fighting Across the Foam
The program begins with the 1917 hit tune "Over There" and its shout to "prepare, say a prayer, send the word, send the word to beware / we'll be over, we're coming over, and we won't come back 'til it's over over there." As a means of getting Americans geared up for war, the political significance is clear. Yet a title from two years earlier, "Don't Send My Darling Boy Away," reflects a sense of uncertainty about America's contributions to the war. The same composer, Albert Von Tilzer, would nonetheless pen "What Kind of American Are You?" with the onset of American hostilities against Germany—its you're-with-us-or-against-us message hammering home the speed at which composers, and perhaps the larger public, had fallen into line in supporting the war effort. The next three songs—"We're All Going Calling on the Kaiser," "Bing! Bang! Bing' Em on the Rhine," and "Tell That to the Marines"—speak for themselves. With frequent derogatory references to "ol' Bill" and his "damn U-boat," they could perhaps even form the basis of a WWI musical subgenre of Kaiser trash-talk tunes. Arthur Fields, Billy Murray, and the American Quartet (in which Murray sang tenor) sing four of the six works, demonstrating their affinity for the genre that will reemerge throughout the program.
The Life of the Soldier, On and Off the Battlefield
"Some day I'm going to murder the bugler" is how Irving Berlin envisions a frustrated recruit forced to rise and shine, in "Oh! How I Hate to Get Up in the Morning." Arthur Fields performs this tune as well as a duet with Grace Woods titled "I Don't Want to Get Well," which depicts a soldier wishing to stay wounded in order to keep the attentions of a beautiful nurse. "The Battle in the Air" is an example of a "descriptive specialty"—a type of short narrative story recorded on early discs and cylinders—adapted to WWI (listen to a program), including a dramatic climax in the form of an aerial dogfight. More thespian action by the American Quartet continues underwater in "The Submarine Attack."
Love During Wartime
The cylinder recording format reached the peak of its popularity in the first ten years of the 20th century, a time when 19th century popular music styles remained prevalent. One of the most widespread genres of the era was the sentimental love song. However, 20th century songwriters recognized the corniness of the genre and infused songs with gentle humor. America's entrance into the war provided composers with topical grist for their wit. In "If He Can Fight Like He Can Love, Goodnight Germany," Mary confidently sings of her beau, just departed for the war. Asserting that if "he's just half as good in a trench, as he was in the park on a bench," she reminds listeners ninety years hence that their great-grandparents’ popular music, too, included sexual innuendos. Unlike Mary, Rosie Green, in "Oh! Frenchy," heads to France after enlisting as an American nurse and falls for a "soldier from Paree." The increasing role of women in the war effort enabled popular composers to consider women in other situations than that of motherhood and "spooning under the silvery moon"; all the same, Rosie Green's interest in "Frenchy" is equal to that of working on the front lines, so perhaps not much of a leap forward for gender parity. Con Conrad enjoyed his work so much that he wrote a sequel, "Frenchy, Come to Yankee Land." The jaunty tune "Send Me a Curl" returns to old-fashioned sentimental love song territory, in which a soldier pines for a lock of his love's hair as a memento of their happiness back home and away from the war.
The Fight Viewed from the Home Front
A somewhat more jaundiced view of domestic bliss can be heard in "I'd Feel At Home If They'd Let Me Join the Army," one man's ode to the military life as a means of escaping his wife. "Sister Susie's Sewing Shirts for Soldiers" ostensibly begins with the praiseworthy war contributions of one young woman. Her effort is regrettably in vain, though, as "some soldiers send epistles, say they'd sooner sleep on thistles, than the saucy, soft, short shirts for soldiers, sister Susie sews." And when not writing timeless love songs, the songwriters of the era would occasionally directly incorporate the issues of the day into their lyrics. The events of the 'teens are hard to miss in "All Those in Favor Say Aye," when the lodge master played by Arthur Fields requests a show of hands on the war, Prohibition, the Salvation Army, and the Bolsheviks.
War Perpetuates the Status Quo
Just as the sentimental ballad was refurbished with the addition of war-related thematic material, so too were the popular genres whose lyrics are most likely to offend modern sensibilities—the "coon" song, the "Indian love-song," and the "rube" sketch. Before he became a star country singer, Vernon Dalhart performs in what was then a relatively common character type, as an African-American longing for the old southern days. In "I'm Goin' to Fight My Way Right Back to Carolina," the historical falsehoods common to songs of this era have been reconfigured in the context of wartime. Likewise, in "Indianola," Billy Murray assumes the stereotype of the "redman chief" who hears the call of war and heads off to "tomahawk the Kaiser." In a similar fashion, the "rube" archetype frequently played by such performers as Cal Stewart in his Uncle Josh sketches is redeployed in "Long Boy," which tells the story of a country bumpkin type who heads to war without really knowing why.
Remembering the Troops
The program concludes with three tunes honoring "the boys," as soldiers were commonly called in popular song. In "Young America, We're Strong For You," Irving Kaufman pays tribute to the fighting men and women when he exclaims, "You're the rising generation, the backbone of the nation, Young America, we're strong for you!" James F. Harrison sings of the soldiers' safe return in "When the Boys Come Home," performed in full-throated declamatory vocal style. And in an unusual recording by the horn-averse pioneer of recorded sound, Thomas A. Edison asks us to remember the bravery of the American men and women, as well as the European allies, in "Let Us Not Forget."
An initiative of the UC Santa Barbara Library • (805) 893-5444 • Santa Barbara, CA 93106-9010. Direct questions or comments about the project or this page to the project staff or visit the help pages.
The minstrel boy - James C. McAuliffe. (Edison Gold Moulded Record: 8487), [between 1904 and 1908].
Listen to a podcast or live stream of a recreation of a typical American vaudeville show on Cylinder Radio
Copyright and licensing information